|

THIS ONE! The 1951 one! The one where Alastair Sim plays Scrooge! UBER-CURMUDGEON! Nobody plays a better Scrooge than this guy. His face is liquid and his voice, positively satanic. Beggars run away from him in the streets. No other Scrooge does the personality changeover better than Alastair Sim. I believe how ugly and horrible he is before the fateful Ghost visits and I believe his transformation when he finally wakes up.
Does anyone know about the dialogue, played-to-the-hilt realism, attitude and personalities in this film? Every exchange has meaning and color and significance. There's no filler, just great content busting out at the seams.
Michael Hordern plays the scariest Jacob Marley. During his first scene as the warning ghost, everytime he moves forward, the camera switches into his point of view. So we're walking step by step towards Ebenezer's frightened, lunatic face. Scares the brains outta me.
The Ghost of Christmas Past takes Ebenezer to a break up with the only woman he ever loved. She says, "I release you. You judge everything by gains" and a young Ebenezer says fine and storms out for good. She collapses and sobs that classic 50s sob. I know honey, doesn't it suck? You'll cry with her. Present day Ebenezer watches all this and clutches his chest. I found myself screaming, "That's right! Grab that stone!"
After Ebenezer's ephipany, he heads over to his nephew's house for dinner. The maid takes his coat, hat and gloves and stares at him in cautious wonder knowing how fantastical it is that he showed up at all. He seems apprehensive to enter the room where the music is coming from. As he's about to open the doors, he turns and looks at the maid over his shoulder. An angelic, compassionate smile glows on her face and she nods to him in encouragement. He warms, lowers his eyes and finds the love and strength to go on in. I get weepy everytime.
Yeah I know it's a black and white, scritchy-scratchy, recorded in mono film. Forget about all the other Scrooges. Just rent it if you can find it.
|